Exeter Socialists ARTICLES AND DISCUSSIONS INDEX

Discussion forum: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ExeterSocialists/

Important Announcement:
-----------------------

Our outgoing Treasurer has shown us a letter about the Exeter Community Centre (download). Please read this and, if possible, attend the Devon County Council's Executive meeting on 23 September 2008.

MEETINGS

NB: Exeter Socialists Discussion Meetings are now to be held on the SECOND Thursday of every month at 7pm to 9pm

at the Heavitree Room in the Exeter Community Centre, St David’s Hill.
Meetings are open to all socialists or to anyone who is interested!
See write-up of previous meeting.

Next meeting:

Thursday 13th November

Topic: 'Re-localisation,
and the (potential) for Radicalism in the Transition Towns Movement'
--------------------------------------------------------------------


Previous meeting:

Thursday 9th October

The Topic for this meeting was to have been:'The politics of community care.' Unfortunately, the comrade who was to have introduced this discussion was unwell, and so the group discussed the current economic situation.

top


Meetings prior to that were:
----------------------------

Thursday 11th September, Topic: 'What is working class struggle?'
See 'How can workers struggle in the period of capitalism’s decline?'

***

Thursday 14 August, Topic: 'The Decomposition of Capitalism?'
See 'Is Capitalism in Decline?', paper by GB, 10/8/08
See also forum message from DP, and JX, re 'Decadence Theories'
There was also a discussion

***

Thursday 3 July, Topic: 'How can workers in the (historically) industrial centres work with those in 'developing' countries?'
See Paper by KX; and write-up of discussion.

***

Thursday 5 June, Topic: Anti-Zionism and Racism
See paper by DP and write-up of discussion.
Supporters of Exeter Palestine Solidarity Campaign attended the meeting.

***

May 1 2008, Topic: 'The Ideology and Politics of Food production'
See Paper by CM, including summary of discussion

***

April 10 2008, Topic: 'Can there be good as well as bad capitalism?'
See Paper by RC, and write-up of discussion

***

March 13 2008, Topic: 'Crime and Punishment'
See Paper by GB, and write-up of discussion.

***

Thursday 7 February 2008
Plans and topics for this meeting were set aside, and instead we had a discussion about our group and its prospects. We are concerned, of course, that there are currently few active members, but we believe we offer something special: the opportunity to 'sound off' about concerns locally, nationally and globally; the opportunity to have intelligent, open discussions about the causes of various problems and how they might be addressed; and continuing the aim of the Socialist Alliance, which was to bring socialists together, despite the trend towards sectarianism and fragmentation. We enjoy the variety of personal positions held by those currently involved. We are keeping this web site (with its store of articles and write-ups) and the discussion forum going, and meeting regularly once a month, and we believe that in due course interest will revive.

***

Thursday 6 December 2007, Topic: The History of Socialist Thought
See Write up of this discussion, including download of handout and links.

***

Thursday 1 November 2007, Topic: Recent events involving the SWP and Respect
See Write-up of discussion

***

Thursday 4 October 2007, Topic: The Future of the Left
Following on from the discussion in August on ‘The Labour Party, What's Left?’, JT led a discussion on how the Left may develop in the future. Write up of discussion by CM.

***

Thursday 6 September 2007, Topic: Housing in Crisis: What Future for the 21st Century?
SE introduced the topic with a paper on the history and background to the various housing issues in Britain: homelessness, insecurity of tenure, lack of affordable homes etc. Then there was a discussion on the curernt situation, nationally and in the Exeter area, see Discussion write-up.

At this meeting an outstanding matter of business was dealt with: the winding up of Exeter Socialist Alliance and closure of its bank account.

***

Thursday 2 August 2007, Topic: The Labour Party, What's Left?
DP introduced the meeting and tabled a handout, which he provided later in amended form via the discussion forum. This paper: The Labour Party, What's Left?, is available here as a web page. See also The Labour Party, What's Left? - group discussion

***

Thursday 5 July 2007, Topic: Brazil

the young Brazilian army officers movement of 1920/30’s, the Prestes (revolutionary) Column (15.000 mile fighting march thru interior of Brazil), the life of Luiz Carlos Prestes (1898 – 1990) and how this interweaves with the present day army officer nationalistic leftist militancy in Venezuela – all linked to Simon Bolivar who liberated part of S. America from Spanish occupation and gave his name to the country of Bolivia

The speaker, BE, gave a fascinating talk, based on his paper on the Prestes Column. Questions and discussion followed.

***

Thursday 7 June 2007, Topic: ‘Socialism and Health’ (paper by GB)

Comments and questions

***

Thursday May 3 2007, Topic: ‘Socialism and Climate Change’ see flyer (pdf download). Notes taken at this meeting have been written up, see link. Comments and corrections welcome.

Also on this topic:

Heat by George Monbiot. A very useful book on the subject of climate change. Prior to our next meeting, I thought it might be useful to give a link to some of George Monbiot’s articles on the subject, see:

http://www.monbiot.com/archives/category/climate-change/

What Mobbiot advocates in Heat is summarised in a short article, here:

http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2006/10/31/heres-the-plan/#more-1027

I find his arguments quite compelling. The point I have greatest difficulty with from a socialist perspective is the carbon rationing scheme for individuals (point 2) – although as he points out in Heat the effect would be redistributive in terms of wealth.

cheers

DP

The Exeter Socialists group have returned to holding regular monthly discussion meetings. If you are interested in keeping in touch with socialist news and debate, I would recommend joining the Exeter Socialists discussion forum, to do this send an e-mail to:

ExeterSocialists-subscribe@yahoogroups.com

The list is open to all socialists – you don’t have to be a member or supporter of the Exeter Socialists.

Previous meetings:

Wednesday 4 April 2007, at City Gate, St Davids Hill, Exeter

Save Sadiq Akabar Campaign 6/4/07

Protest against visit to University of Dr Stephen Cambone, aide to Donald Rumsfeld 23/3/07

Campaign for a New Workers Party
--------------------------------

What kind of new party do we need?
----------------------------------

Note: this site has been mothballed since the Exeter Socialists group ceased to meet on a regular basis, however occasional news items are being added, and there is some interesting past stuff on here, including articles below.

------------------
Exeter Socialists
------------------
'Who are we?' etc.

Last updated 24/2/06, see LATEST

Site open to comments, ideas and contributions!

Our next meeting: time and venue to be advised
----------------------------------------------

We need ideas for how to resume socialist activity and discussions in Exeter. Meanwhile, there is our discussion group, where we can explore 'What's caused this lull on the Left? How do we (or what needs to change to) get things going again?' It's not just our group, by the way...

 

G8 Blockades - special report by J.O. with links to photos - 14 July 2005
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

SWP and Gilad Atzmon – DP (29 June 2005)
-------------------------

Report of meeting, May 10th 2005
--------------------------------

We had a lively discussion on the results of the General Election, including 'Election as Myth' and an analysis of the results from a Leftie perspective; see GB's comments on 'Interpreting a Candidate's Votes'. We discussed the reasons why votes for the Left were so low, and how this could change by the next significant election. Would an economic downturn, making people feel insecure and dissatisfied, incline them 'Leftwards'? How would a crisis of oil getting seriously expensive due to being past-its-peak and/or more obvious climate change affect capitalism and the political climate? What vision of an alternative socialist society have we to offer anyway? More questions than answers, but a stimulating exchange of views and ideas.

Comrades have their say (do contributors want their names used?)
------------------------

G.B. on 'Interpreting a Candidate's Votes'. (11/5/05)

A topical contribution from 'B.E.' entitled 'Did You Know?' (22/3/05)

For further contributions, see below.

Report of Exeter Socialists meeting at 7:30pm Tuesday, April 12
---------------------------------------------------------------

There was discussion about the current low level of interest in the Left (not only affecting our group) and what we should do about it. It was felt that part of the problem is not really having a vision of future socialist society to offer, so we intend to have discussions on this topic, within the group initially, and then in an advertised public meeting with an invited speaker. We also talked about capitalism encountering a crisis due to the depletion of oil and other resources, which can be seen as invalidating some socialist ideas about how the transition to socialism will come about. (See 'Potential Abundance?')

Report of Exeter Socialists meeting at 7:30pm Tuesday, March 22
---------------------------------------------------------------

Dave and Bill reported back on the Socialist Alliance Democratic Platform Conference on March 12. 50 comrades from various Left groups around the country attended, and several motions were debated and voted on. The main agreement reached was to set up a 'Provisional Socialist Alliance' as a step towards a new SA which will be launched at a Conference in the autumn. A press release was issued following the event.
We agreed that Exeter Socialists would do our part towards the autumn launch by networking in the South West to make links with comrades interested in joining a democratic and open republican socialist party.

Report of Exeter Socialists meeting at 7:30pm Tuesday, March 8
--------------------------------------------------------------

We met to discuss strategy for the forthcoming elections. It was evident that we don't have sufficient support for putting up a parliamentary candidate (see 'Socialist Challenge' below). However, we feel a responsibility to voters to field socialist candidates for local elections, and we will meet that as best we can. Further discussions will take place at our meeting on March 22nd.

We discussed the apparent downturn in interest in the Left, and felt that sectarianism is part of the problem. A representative of our group will be going to the Conference on March 12th 2005, where 'organising for a mass workers’ party' is the primary focus: see Discussion Bulletin and Latest news above.

A Socialist Challenge at the General Election in Exeter?
---------------------------------------------------------

The General Election will be upon us very soon - should there be a socialist candidate standing in Exeter? Should there be a socialist challenge to the neo-conservative politics of New Labour?

Ideally the answer to this will be ‘Yes’ but we have to decide whether we have the resources and whether it is the best use of our resources to stand a candidate.

The Exeter Socialists stood two candidates in the City Council elections in 2004. We have been discussing standing candidates again in the County Council elections this year. We have the resources to stand 2 or 3 candidates in the County elections.

Realistically we need around 30 activists and we need to raise a few thousand pounds to make a General Election campaign viable. This is not impossible - we did this in 2001 with the Socialist Alliance but our forces have since been diminished by the closing down of the Socialist Alliance.

The Exeter Socialists are realistic - we are only expecting to have the resources to fight the local elections - but we would love to be proved wrong. Come to the meeting and help us decide the best way to keep socialism on the agenda in Exeter in the elections.

Who are the 'Exeter Socialists'?
Meetings
Study Group
Contact details
Articles

Who are the 'Exeter Socialists'?
--------------------------------

The 'Exeter Socialists' are backing a Conference on March 12th 2005 in Birmingham at which a new Democratic Socialist Alliance will be launched. There has never been a greater need for a socialist alternative to 'New Labour'.

In Scotland almost the entire Left is united in the 'Scottish Socialist Party' - in England the Left is fragmented across numerous competing groups all of whom pose as 1917-style Bolshevik parties. We bleieve the working class needs a new democratic socialist party - a pluralist socialist party with room inside for all the existing socialist groups.

Fot a time the 'Socialist Alliance' looked as if it could have been the precursor to a united socialist party in England. Instead, after 10 years in existence, it was shut down in favour of the SWP's project, the 'Respect Unity Coalition'. A substantial part of the 'Socialist Alliance', notably almost all the independents, opposed this development.

The 'Exeter Socialists' was formed in 2004 by independents from the 'Socialist Alliance'. We see ourselves as a continuation of the spirit of the 'Socialist Alliance' and if anything we are now a broader and more diiverse movement that is subversive and liberating and above all extremely democratic. Do Join Us!

Meetings:
---------

We have meetings for discussion and business at
7:30pm, 2nd and 4th Tuesdays of each month
at King Ludd Bookshop, New Bridge Street, Exeter.

Study Group
------------

We plan to have a Study Group meeting once a month. Globalisation, war, under-development, climate change: these are all features of modern capitalism. The Study Group aims to grapple with theoretical critiques of capitalism by studying the original: 'primary', Marxist texts* , with a view to understanding the capitalist world today.
Our next meeting will be at 7:30pm, Thurs 3rd March, King Ludd Bookshop, New Bridge Street, Exeter, when we will be discussing the Communist Manifesto. Do come along! Download leaflet

* Suggested texts for individual, or future group, study.

top

Contact us:
------------

email: davep@exeterleft.freeserve.co.uk
Postal address: Exeter Socialists, PO Box 185, Exeter

Articles and Discussion hand-outs or notes
------------------------------------------

Our regular, twice monthly, meetings have generally been a mixture of discussion and business. Some of these have been captured as hand-outs or notes, including:

'Marx and Marxism' hand-out 20 July 2004
'What is a United Front?'17 August 2004
'Is Veganism (part of) the Solution?' 7 September 2004
'The Brazilian Workers Party' November 2004 ?
'Socialism and Spirituality' hand-out 21 December 2004

Further contributions:
'Did You Know?' 22 March 2005
'The 1930s Labour Movement' 17 August 2004

NB: These talks reflect the interests of individual members and do not necessarily reflect shared beliefs or ethos of the 'Exeter Socialists' group.

If anyone has more notes of these or other discussions they'd like added to the site, please let me have them, preferable by email, or typed for scanning in, but I'll type them up if they're interesting. CM

New web site
--------------

The Exeter Socialists web site has been transferred from http://www.exeterleft.freeserve.co.uk to a new site currently managed by Chris Marsh. The site is - conspicuously, I hope - not yet designed. My guidance so far has been: 'No flashy gizmos, make it new, keep it up-to-date.' So please contact me with design ideas, especially urls of sites we could emulate/ learn from, but most importantly with MATERIAL: events, articles, reviews, commentary on current events etc. etc.

One idea for the web site is for comrades who don't have their own web site to have their own page here - to their own design - with the address www.exetersocialists.org.uk/marysmith.htm

top

Marxist Study Group – Suggested Texts
--------------------------------------
by Jon Owen

What I've prepared here, is a selection of predominately 'marxist' texts, aiming at an all round and general scope of marxian study. Obviously, this is just a suggestion, and can be totally discarded if needs be.
First things first:
a) Political Economy

Karl Marx:
• Capital, volumes 1 to 3
• Wage Labour and Capital + Value Price and Profit
• Grundrisse
• 1844 Manuscripts
• The Poverty of Philosophy

Others:
• Bonefeld -Open Marxism (in 3 shortish volumes)
• Harvey -Limits to Capital
• Proudhon -What is Property?

b) Critique of the State

Karl Marx :
• Critique of the Gotha Program
• 18th Brumaire of Louis 14th
• Critique of Hegel's philosophy of right
• The Civil war in France
• The Class Struggle in France
• Conspectus of Bakunin's Statism and Anarchy

Others :
• Bakunin: God and the State; Statism and Anarchy; Marxism, freedom and the state; Stateless Socialism -anarchism; The Paris commune and the idea of State
• Rosa Luxemburg: Reform or Revolution; The Mass Strike, the Party, Trade Unions
• Pashukanis: Law and Marxism
• Peter Kropotkin: The State: Its Historic Role
• Michel Foucault: The Archaeology of Knowledge; Discipline and Punish .Lenin: The state and revolution

c) Marxism and Philosophy

Obviously, the selection here is virtually unlimited. But there are, of course, certain things, which stand out. Personally, I have relatively little grounding in philosophy and its history. So, it might be a good idea to get one's head around a few things first:
• Plato: The Republic;
• Aristotle: Metaphysics; Ethics. (It's worth noting here, that you can find a really good summary of most of these crucial writers on the 'Internet Encyclopaedia of Philosophy', the address of which is below).
• Kant: Critique of Pure Reason; Metaphysic of Morality; Critique of Judgement. (IEP)
• Hegel: Phenomenology of the Spirit; The Philosophy of History; The Philosophy of Right
• Marx: Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844; The German Ideology; The Poverty of Philosophy

It seems that there are a few major writers on 'dialectics'. A few suggestions: Hyppolite, Adorno, Lukacs, Marcuse, JP Satre, Horkheimer , Lenin&Trotsky, Dunyevskaya ...and so on.

Other topics that could be considered?
Phenomenology + Existentialism
Phenomenology vs. Structuralism
Theory of Knowledge
Art: Futurism, Dadaism, Surrealism etc
History: the Russian Revolution, and the Soviet Union
Globalisation and its fallout
Ecology and Revolution
Sustainability
The First, Second, Third and Fourth International
The Paris Commune
The Spanish Civil War
Fascism in Germany and Italy
Leninism/Trotskyism/Writings of Antonio Gramsci
Psychology and Linguistics
History of, and contemporary Feminist theory
Education
Anarchism, Anarcho-syndicalism, Anarcho-communism: Bookchin, Guerin, Kropotkin, Goldman, Sorel, Proudhon, Malatesta, Bakunin, Rocker Chomsky
The Situationists

Useful resources:
Nearly everything to do with Marx, and most 'marxist' writers can be found at www.marxists.org
A really interesting site about the situationists: www.nothingness.org
A site with a comprehensive 'libertarian marxist' reading list (on which this list is roughly based): www.endpage.com
Finally, another really fantastic site, is the Internet Encyclopaedia of Philosophy www.utm.edu/research/iep

top